These are both very different roles: one, in most cases, is hands-on and the other is to step back as birth unfolds.
It is possible for a birth photographer and a doula to be successful in one combined role. However, it requires careful management of the two distinct roles and clear communication with clients.
When I first started working in birth, I began as a birth photographer. It truly (and I mean this from the bottom of my heart) was a “come to Jesus” moment. I discovered what I was meant to do with my life. But then COVID came knocking on the world’s door, and I was no longer allowed into hospitals. My heart hurt for those who had babies in hospitals with no support at all.
After taking doula training, I wondered why it had taken me so long. By making sure to bring my camera, my ‘doula hat’, and my clients are better served.
What are the Benefits of Having One Person Being Both Doula and Birth Photographer?
The first thing that comes to mind as a major benefit is fewer people in your birth space. By reducing the number of people in the room, the birth experience can feel more private and comfortable.
The extended time spent with the client during prenatal meetings and the birth itself can foster a deeper level of trust and comfort. Oftentimes, I do not meet (in person) a client if I am only doing birth photography. The birth space is the first time meeting, which sometimes can be awkward.
Finally, a combined service can be more affordable than hiring two separate professionals.
What are Some Potential Drawbacks of One Person Being a Doula and Birth Photographer?
Many people think true multitasking is impossible. They argue that one person can’t fully focus on both helping someone physically and taking every important photo at the same time. This is a completely valid concern. This is why communication is crucial during prenatal visits. During these visits, it is my job not only to educate the mom, but also their partner. It is my duty to have that partner as prepared as possible with comfort measures, possible scenarios, breathwork, among other skills. I don’t expect them to remember all of this at the time of birth, but I can step in and say, “Remember when we did this or applied pressure there”? I step back into the photographer role once that is taken care of.
During these prenatal meetings, we will also discuss priorities. If it comes to a point that a mom needs full hands-on help, beyond what her partner is providing, I will put down the camera and help until the partner can take over. That said, we will discuss what the family wants. “Would you like me to continue to photograph, or would you like me to step in”?
Because the role of doula+photographer (doulatog) is less common, a solo doulatog may lack the backup structure common for dedicated professionals. This is true. Fewer people are both, but here in the LA area, I find most birth photographers are both. If a suitable backup cannot be found in a particular area, the speaker will communicate this to the client and discuss other options.
How Do You Decide If You Want One Person for Both Roles or Separate People for the Roles?
If you prioritize hands-on support above all else, a dedicated doula may be the best choice.
For the highest quality and most thorough photographic documentation, hiring a dedicated birth photographer is likely your best option.
If you prefer a smaller, more personal birth team and appreciate the savings of hiring one professional, choosing a doulatog could be ideal—as long as you communicate and agree on your priorities in advance. A doulatog truly can offer the best of both worlds.